Librarything vs Tinycat: Which is Better?
LibraryThing and TinyCat are closely related, but they serve different purposes:
- LibraryThing is a personal book cataloging tool designed for bibliophiles, researchers, and collectors.
- TinyCat is a library management system built on LibraryThing, meant for small libraries, nonprofits, schools, and religious institutions.
Let’s compare them in detail:
1. Purpose & Audience
- LibraryThing: Best for individuals who want to catalog and organize personal book collections.
- TinyCat: Best for small libraries that need a circulation system with patron management and lending features.
2. Book Cataloging & Organization
- LibraryThing: Allows detailed metadata entry, including ISBNs, tags, reviews, and Dewey Decimal Classification.
- TinyCat: Uses LibraryThing’s cataloging system but adds lending, check-in/check-out, and patron management tools.
3. Lending & Patron Management
- LibraryThing: No lending system—it’s for personal collections only.
- TinyCat: Includes patron accounts, check-in/check-out features, due dates, fines, and borrowing history tracking.
4. Ease of Use & Interface
- LibraryThing: Has a somewhat outdated, complex interface focused on metadata and book lovers.
- TinyCat: Offers a modern, clean library catalog interface that makes it easy for patrons to browse collections.
5. Social & Community Features
- LibraryThing: Has discussion forums, book swaps, and an Early Reviewer program for book lovers.
- TinyCat: Not a social platform, but it allows patrons to see available books and submit borrowing requests.
6. Pricing & Subscription
- LibraryThing: Free for up to 200 books, then $25 for a lifetime unlimited membership.
- TinyCat: Subscription-based, starting at $3/month for small libraries (up to 1,000 books), with pricing increasing based on the collection size.
7. Integration & Export Options
- LibraryThing: Supports ISBN lookups, barcode scanning, and imports from public libraries.
- TinyCat: Uses LibraryThing’s catalog but adds library-specific tools, including searchable OPAC (Online Public Access Catalog) functionality.
Which One Should You Use?
- Use LibraryThing if you are an individual wanting to catalog and track personal book collections.
- Use TinyCat if you are running a small library or organization that needs a lending system with patron management.
For personal book tracking, LibraryThing is better. For library lending and management, TinyCat is the superior choice! 📚✨