Novelist vs Scrivener: Which is Better?

When it comes to writing tools, the market is full of options designed to cater to different writing styles, preferences, and goals. Among these tools, Novelist and Scrivener stand out as two of the most popular and powerful writing applications. Whether you’re a novelist, screenwriter, or simply someone looking for a better way to organize your writing projects, understanding the differences between these two tools is crucial in making an informed decision.

What is Novelist?

Novelist is a writing software specifically designed for novelists and fiction writers. It offers a structured and flexible environment for writers who want to stay organized while working on their writing projects. The tool is built with the writer’s workflow in mind, helping writers to develop plots, characters, chapters, and settings, all while keeping everything in one place.

Key Features of Novelist:

Story Development Tools: Novelist provides tools to organize plotlines, create character profiles, and define settings. Writers can outline their story and keep track of key plot points.
Writing Interface: The writing interface is clean and minimalist, designed to reduce distractions and help writers focus on the task at hand.
Chapter and Scene Organization: Writers can break down their story into chapters and scenes, making it easier to manage long and complex writing projects.
Progress Tracking: Novelist allows writers to track their progress by word count and set goals, which can help maintain momentum.
Character and Setting Profiles: Writers can create detailed profiles for characters, locations, and other story elements to keep consistency throughout the writing process.
Distraction-Free Writing Mode: Focus mode is available to help writers eliminate distractions and stay immersed in their creative process.

What is Scrivener?

Scrivener is one of the most renowned writing software applications in the world. Developed by Literature and Latte, Scrivener is designed for writers of all types — novelists, screenwriters, journalists, academic writers, and more. It offers a comprehensive set of tools for managing large writing projects and organizing ideas, research, and drafts.

Key Features of Scrivener:

Binder System: Scrivener’s powerful “binder” system lets you organize your writing by breaking it down into manageable parts (chapters, scenes, research, notes, etc.). You can move sections of your manuscript around easily with drag-and-drop.
Outlining Tools: Scrivener provides extensive outlining and structuring options, allowing you to create storyboards, corkboards, and other tools to organize and plan your work.
Split-View Editor: Writers can view multiple sections of their manuscript at once by splitting the screen, allowing for a side-by-side comparison of different parts of their work.
Research Storage: Scrivener allows you to store your research directly in the project file, making it easy to reference notes, articles, or images without leaving the writing environment.
Formatting and Export Options: Scrivener includes robust options for formatting your manuscript and exporting it to a variety of formats, including ePub, PDF, Word, and Final Draft.
Goal Setting and Tracking: You can set word count targets and track your progress toward reaching your writing goals, helping to stay motivated and on track.

Novelist vs Scrivener: Key Comparisons

To better understand the strengths and weaknesses of Novelist and Scrivener, let’s compare them across several key areas.

1. Focus on Structure and Organization

Novelist: Novelist excels in providing an organized structure for novel writing, with a strong emphasis on helping authors plan and develop their stories. The software allows you to break down your novel into chapters, scenes, and plots, while providing tools to track character development and settings. It is very much focused on the creative process from a storytelling perspective, with tools that enhance organization without overwhelming the user.
Scrivener: Scrivener is a powerhouse when it comes to organization and structure. It provides a more flexible and customizable organization system than Novelist, with its binder system and the ability to create complex outlines, corkboards, and project hierarchies. Scrivener offers features that are useful for both fiction and non-fiction writers, allowing for greater control over project management.

2. User Interface and Ease of Use

Novelist: Novelist has a clean, simple interface that is designed to keep things minimalist and distraction-free. While it is intuitive for new users, it may not have as many advanced features as Scrivener for more experienced users. This makes Novelist a great choice for those who want simplicity and focus in their writing experience.
Scrivener: Scrivener’s interface can appear more complex due to the variety of tools and features it offers. However, for users who take the time to learn the software, Scrivener provides an incredibly powerful and customizable workspace. It may take some time to master the full capabilities of Scrivener, but it provides a high degree of control over how you organize and interact with your project.

3. Writing Tools and Features

Novelist: Novelist’s writing tools are focused mainly on helping writers develop their novel’s structure, plot, and characters. The software’s character and setting profiles, chapter-based organization, and goal-tracking features are ideal for novelists looking for straightforward tools to get their story written. However, it lacks some of the more advanced writing aids found in Scrivener, such as a split-screen editor.
Scrivener: Scrivener provides an extensive set of writing aids that enhance the writing experience. Features like split-view editing, full-screen mode, and the corkboard allow writers to work in a flexible and personalized way. Scrivener also offers more robust support for writing drafts, revisions, and outlines in parallel, making it a better fit for more complex writing projects.

4. Research and Note Management

Novelist: Novelist allows writers to store and organize notes, characters, and settings within the project. The tool also has a basic research management system that allows you to store research information related to your novel.
Scrivener: Scrivener shines when it comes to research and notes management. Writers can store research materials directly in the project binder and access them with ease while writing. The software supports a variety of file formats, such as PDFs, images, and web pages, making it an ideal tool for writers who rely heavily on research.

5. Exporting and Publishing

Novelist: Novelist offers basic exporting options to formats like .txt and .pdf. While these features work for casual writers or those focused on the writing process, they may not be as powerful as Scrivener’s publishing and formatting options.
Scrivener: Scrivener is known for its robust exporting capabilities, supporting a variety of formats suitable for publishing and professional writing. Writers can easily export their work to formats like ePub, Kindle, Word, PDF, and more. Scrivener is well-suited for those looking to publish their writing or submit manuscripts to agents.

6. Platform Availability

Novelist: Novelist is available on Windows and Mac, with a focus on simplicity and minimalism. It’s ideal for those who want a no-frills tool to help them develop their novel.
Scrivener: Scrivener is available on Windows, Mac, and iOS, providing flexibility across different devices. It is a more cross-platform tool, which is a major plus for writers who work on multiple devices.

Which is Better for You?

The answer to this question largely depends on your writing style and needs:

Choose Novelist if:
- You are primarily focused on novel writing and want a simple, distraction-free environment for writing and planning your story.
- You don’t require extensive research management or advanced formatting/exporting features.
- You prefer a minimalist tool that helps you focus on writing and plot development without too many complex options.
Choose Scrivener if:
- You need advanced features for managing large writing projects, especially if you are dealing with complex structures or a mix of writing and research.
- You want more control over the organization of your manuscript and a wider range of exporting options.
- You’re comfortable with a more complex interface and want a tool that can handle both writing and professional publishing needs.

Conclusion

Both Novelist and Scrivener are excellent writing tools, each catering to different types of writers. Novelist is a great choice for those who need a straightforward and organized way to write a novel, whereas Scrivener is a powerful and flexible tool that supports a wide range of writing projects, from novels to screenplays to academic papers. Ultimately, your choice between these two will depend on the complexity of your writing needs, your personal preferences, and the specific tools that align with your writing workflow.

ApexDelight